Policymakers are increasingly exploring the expansion of value-based payment (VBP) in rural settings through new funding opportunities, including the Rural Health Transformation Program, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation models, and state-led policy initiatives. Although rural VBP models can incentivize and enable rural communities to strengthen care coordination, manage population health, and move toward more sustainable approaches to financing care, these models may struggle to achieve intended results when they replicate models that have succeeded in urban health systems. Smaller patient populations, limited provider supply, geographic isolation, and fewer financial and operational resources can fundamentally change what providers need to succeed under alternative payment models in rural areas. Effective rural VBP therefore requires deliberate choices about payment, financial risk, performance measurement, infrastructure, and implementation support.
This paper explores design considerations and strategies Medicaid leaders can use to meet rural providers where they are, while creating a pathway toward greater accountability and care transformation when designing or expanding VBP programs in rural communities. We highlight considerations about financial risk and access preservation, and offer technical design approaches that are suited to rural healthcare delivery. The paper presents a five-part framework that identifies practical strategies Medicaid leaders can use to calibrate financial risk, preserve access, produce credible performance results, align attribution with rural care delivery, and establish fair but ambitious benchmarks.
We discuss the significance and potential approaches for each of the following parts of the framework:
- Calibrating financial risk to rural provider tolerance
- Structuring financial incentives with access as a core goal
- Accounting for limited patient volume when setting performance targets
- Tailoring attribution and accountability to reflect rural care delivery
- Setting benchmarks and expectations with rural realities in mind